{
  "schema": "gpu-video-comparison-review-method/v2",
  "report_sha256": "23665097246549275a2433373f3cf79f1cb05aea58017056c2a08d8bdf81bdce",
  "audio_review_method": "machine",
  "visual_review_method": "assistant_static_frames",
  "decision_method": "orchestrator_or_maintainer_review",
  "human_listened": false,
  "human_viewed": false,
  "audio_reviewed": false,
  "full_motion_reviewed": false,
  "machine_qa_passes": [
    "blind_audio",
    "audio_video"
  ],
  "limitations": [
    "No human listening or viewing was performed in this review process.",
    "The orchestrator inspected contact sheets and a full-resolution still, not full motion.",
    "Machine descriptions may hallucinate or miss artifacts, speech or music.",
    "Sampled frames cannot establish precise audiovisual synchronization.",
    "Machine reports did not automatically approve any clip."
  ],
  "cases": [
    {
      "id": "cabin-wan",
      "video_sha256": "871372d16af38cf95dcfca91b5c3bdd00f3ac654d4125c50d10d5694062edcc8",
      "frame_evidence": {
        "sample_seconds": [
          0,
          1,
          2,
          3,
          4,
          5,
          6,
          7,
          8,
          9,
          10,
          11,
          12,
          13,
          14
        ],
        "contact": {
          "file": "review/cabin-wan-contact.jpg",
          "bytes": 380003,
          "sha256": "8013e8107bf753e7bf250cc4330d542aedb5ec7dfaca6f15bf2b92cda575910b"
        },
        "full_frame_14s": {
          "file": "review/cabin-wan-14s.jpg",
          "bytes": 334755,
          "sha256": "f4c2bbde7c5f658c61ea749e5d14efa941a7edfa07a63896eaa9417122e5bef6"
        }
      },
      "machine_evidence_sha256": {
        "receipt_sha256": "18d7f2919e6f2ce2368e7d7986f4eb36117fe22fc160bc044cd76963c4e63bf0",
        "campaign_sha256": "18a33b1e8e94e845690d4154f471e9e37a4002df85804e46d0c5d982edf095d5",
        "controller_result_sha256": "f3b2c6d6861a78b9a87fd87883e06a10ad572fe9d72b02a118177aca768f4c4f",
        "result_sha256": "b5e55c714ccded306635e96371a1fc171cc26b90629be6bc26840c50a75c94d5",
        "blind_audio_sha256": "2903168ded77c8a31566140b02a4aa557c135db576a59ce9b77b01f00d6afc9f",
        "audio_video_sha256": "23e107e4c2d6311058a23ba3012109cab3a86068a19ef7d11328a0d0793189fe"
      },
      "machine_generation_profile": "thinker-concise-prose-v3",
      "machine_report_termination": {
        "blind_audio": {
          "complete": true,
          "ended_with_eos": true,
          "eos_positions_1based": [
            76
          ],
          "eos_token_id": 151645,
          "raw_tokens_preserved": true,
          "stop_reason": "eos",
          "terminal_token_id": 151645
        },
        "audio_video": {
          "complete": true,
          "ended_with_eos": true,
          "eos_positions_1based": [
            89
          ],
          "eos_token_id": 151645,
          "raw_tokens_preserved": true,
          "stop_reason": "eos",
          "terminal_token_id": 151645
        }
      },
      "machine_report_token_limit_reached": {
        "blind_audio": false,
        "audio_video": false
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "cabin-lightwan",
      "video_sha256": "5049d636450641ffe3fdb8e827eeee0d671deecab25cacb2c71c51e01426273d",
      "frame_evidence": {
        "sample_seconds": [
          0,
          1,
          2,
          3,
          4,
          5,
          6,
          7,
          8,
          9,
          10,
          11,
          12,
          13,
          14
        ],
        "contact": {
          "file": "review/cabin-lightwan-contact.jpg",
          "bytes": 412052,
          "sha256": "bf2bb71743bd52482d26cf21f154971d7cf014b6be91e2d132ce00a2c5e858ff"
        },
        "full_frame_14s": {
          "file": "review/cabin-lightwan-14s.jpg",
          "bytes": 326814,
          "sha256": "db90a5c980e5f84a449e2f7ad9d3946e582f5edf06cb471324345b4a5d16b1d0"
        }
      },
      "machine_evidence_sha256": {
        "receipt_sha256": "f95d8c689158a03964f0daa339d8be5c3a9aae4d0c15f592f87a291ac1a95d43",
        "campaign_sha256": "4c18f53d9fb4f93992ee6294fd60e7190701c9e69192b7452bf24464b8551fdb",
        "controller_result_sha256": "536a5f5bc50acd2564b5e8e81992c95d855d11e86429f9c2a2eebd2eedde717f",
        "result_sha256": "920e0423d98d2085a5613151d9193b20238dc39e1d01e42907889cb0a29691d7",
        "blind_audio_sha256": "eab187ef0cff1ae45b119b6c6931c48ad7e52881c9e79ceb1a78e188f7b7db8d",
        "audio_video_sha256": "27c56a65ce8d1ba5eda1a17e22089c695140d5916ede8332741249e47ae37cd3"
      },
      "machine_generation_profile": "thinker-concise-prose-v3",
      "machine_report_termination": {
        "blind_audio": {
          "complete": true,
          "ended_with_eos": true,
          "eos_positions_1based": [
            96
          ],
          "eos_token_id": 151645,
          "raw_tokens_preserved": true,
          "stop_reason": "eos",
          "terminal_token_id": 151645
        },
        "audio_video": {
          "complete": true,
          "ended_with_eos": true,
          "eos_positions_1based": [
            100
          ],
          "eos_token_id": 151645,
          "raw_tokens_preserved": true,
          "stop_reason": "eos",
          "terminal_token_id": 151645
        }
      },
      "machine_report_token_limit_reached": {
        "blind_audio": false,
        "audio_video": false
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "cabin-ltx",
      "video_sha256": "5f3159d4c8c3168f347fab18525aefb3b11c519e9751ce5a2aba2b9ab8cfcbae",
      "frame_evidence": {
        "sample_seconds": [
          0,
          1,
          2,
          3,
          4,
          5,
          6,
          7,
          8,
          9,
          10,
          11,
          12,
          13,
          14
        ],
        "contact": {
          "file": "review/cabin-ltx-contact.jpg",
          "bytes": 382112,
          "sha256": "4519e72766989ca9aeaa5b62a6bf4a0bd2d30348b3951d28da5f0d983c369aac"
        },
        "full_frame_14s": {
          "file": "review/cabin-ltx-14s.jpg",
          "bytes": 231592,
          "sha256": "ff5f056d7eb10d8939e6f8c4e0c450558d5d2a4c3195c13fafc1faa1f95a638f"
        }
      },
      "machine_evidence_sha256": {
        "receipt_sha256": "ba1adc2be30049e9c748b5c11dc3f3f3bf6d6d1eabbc25799910f94dd4bfff17",
        "campaign_sha256": "b0f0fc35d9c0b343b9b588029d2d99a55b3533bc40041d271fc7c772d74c891a",
        "controller_result_sha256": "88231bb050615fbf6a14fda49864c98c4b8190856dad2ee547c3f428b1b22791",
        "result_sha256": "35ce811502328011db74d3e0eb1fe64ee668aeab78b255015c4ce82f96b484cf",
        "blind_audio_sha256": "47225057255c5378c59e85da00139af5b31fa05c79b2171ac07b6774680522b4",
        "audio_video_sha256": "0f237d1d833c84a72a63348d055d881278957bbf9e9d3718b437c12f38141345"
      },
      "machine_generation_profile": "thinker-concise-prose-v3",
      "machine_report_termination": {
        "blind_audio": {
          "complete": true,
          "ended_with_eos": true,
          "eos_positions_1based": [
            88
          ],
          "eos_token_id": 151645,
          "raw_tokens_preserved": true,
          "stop_reason": "eos",
          "terminal_token_id": 151645
        },
        "audio_video": {
          "complete": true,
          "ended_with_eos": true,
          "eos_positions_1based": [
            111
          ],
          "eos_token_id": 151645,
          "raw_tokens_preserved": true,
          "stop_reason": "eos",
          "terminal_token_id": 151645
        }
      },
      "machine_report_token_limit_reached": {
        "blind_audio": false,
        "audio_video": false
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rally-lightwan",
      "video_sha256": "48680526688060cc01a3dc180565071ab8baf8c5325af18d0ff53d439d784b62",
      "frame_evidence": {
        "sample_seconds": [
          0,
          1,
          2,
          3,
          4,
          5,
          6,
          7,
          8,
          9,
          10,
          11,
          12,
          13,
          14
        ],
        "contact": {
          "file": "review/rally-lightwan-contact.jpg",
          "bytes": 519470,
          "sha256": "3441198208f2927c6ce0fe3cd1def0e4c93b0a57e74041e4e83a7f62e8031a3e"
        },
        "full_frame_14s": {
          "file": "review/rally-lightwan-14s.jpg",
          "bytes": 341292,
          "sha256": "9990f037c84ca2addcbb4e1aeb547b1e2ca415d224e35ea0fa39a3ef26465c20"
        }
      },
      "machine_evidence_sha256": {
        "receipt_sha256": "d83618b9d343511eaaa37cf9b9d037e657b33b6b76227cfc6c452469acde67eb",
        "campaign_sha256": "31c1e8b929895709488baee6046364f795d1c21313bdca7e2ba21e89ec290ba9",
        "controller_result_sha256": "8078052c74667a4460940078726e85ff4fb51b10b84685b1c710a8ddd24d9cc3",
        "result_sha256": "450e2cd6b2decf7076a331514eca26ac15518e4a1115abe7eb6d2055d3d4441f",
        "blind_audio_sha256": "828e630cb49ec3857d64c44f2c3b4ff5ee08166e088d56a0d5738364b09b90aa",
        "audio_video_sha256": "bf0ae7c2754d9095e1cb3ffe3b9c07ee6d61b7e23ccd6d6e02fef379aa95f34d"
      },
      "machine_generation_profile": "thinker-concise-prose-v3",
      "machine_report_termination": {
        "blind_audio": {
          "complete": true,
          "ended_with_eos": true,
          "eos_positions_1based": [
            97
          ],
          "eos_token_id": 151645,
          "raw_tokens_preserved": true,
          "stop_reason": "eos",
          "terminal_token_id": 151645
        },
        "audio_video": {
          "complete": true,
          "ended_with_eos": true,
          "eos_positions_1based": [
            86
          ],
          "eos_token_id": 151645,
          "raw_tokens_preserved": true,
          "stop_reason": "eos",
          "terminal_token_id": 151645
        }
      },
      "machine_report_token_limit_reached": {
        "blind_audio": false,
        "audio_video": false
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rally-ltx",
      "video_sha256": "0c05c182df3d4a40c1b05f73cabcd42e925b5212046fb2a67fca07662fd6ad68",
      "frame_evidence": {
        "sample_seconds": [
          0,
          1,
          2,
          3,
          4,
          5,
          6,
          7,
          8,
          9,
          10,
          11,
          12,
          13,
          14
        ],
        "contact": {
          "file": "review/rally-ltx-contact.jpg",
          "bytes": 421848,
          "sha256": "6cb18a86fd9686ac719abd3eb1e898298e11a37e1c5738cbeeda98882a3673fe"
        },
        "full_frame_14s": {
          "file": "review/rally-ltx-14s.jpg",
          "bytes": 154098,
          "sha256": "65a1590ad75482fd038ad5c2b444a9692757f091326bc453fab0241c84a2bebe"
        }
      },
      "machine_evidence_sha256": {
        "receipt_sha256": "e6a33c87e1c13367da3c9d173fd3c70eff8e05067c142003b5b7b1dede13ae23",
        "campaign_sha256": "1fccbb54a822edb749c967427b9fd6eb141d488fca7b2e6222d3255cee364f9f",
        "controller_result_sha256": "34f08fb275f49dd75de0c703aef7ebb25de2ec5c76b43c6a3ea1e69f1fb70068",
        "result_sha256": "7dad78def86341d4750b0433f540069c4adc91d3e08470191a043cd42a010c86",
        "blind_audio_sha256": "62280a6ee8044cbddf06096ed2ab781fd7ed9c532e2d4208776c81dc99ac9b84",
        "audio_video_sha256": "e21abc33bb918165b1c6e17732801ad36968f2f654bbe0ca1b91d9f9911c9dd4"
      },
      "machine_generation_profile": "thinker-concise-prose-v3",
      "machine_report_termination": {
        "blind_audio": {
          "complete": true,
          "ended_with_eos": true,
          "eos_positions_1based": [
            83
          ],
          "eos_token_id": 151645,
          "raw_tokens_preserved": true,
          "stop_reason": "eos",
          "terminal_token_id": 151645
        },
        "audio_video": {
          "complete": true,
          "ended_with_eos": true,
          "eos_positions_1based": [
            73
          ],
          "eos_token_id": 151645,
          "raw_tokens_preserved": true,
          "stop_reason": "eos",
          "terminal_token_id": 151645
        }
      },
      "machine_report_token_limit_reached": {
        "blind_audio": false,
        "audio_video": false
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "rally-wan",
      "video_sha256": "17ff527895148ae29aa71d4293de1932a3b25c6bdd509fbcaef6c76f89c5fbaa",
      "frame_evidence": {
        "sample_seconds": [
          0,
          1,
          2,
          3,
          4,
          5,
          6,
          7,
          8,
          9,
          10,
          11,
          12,
          13,
          14
        ],
        "contact": {
          "file": "review/rally-wan-contact.jpg",
          "bytes": 379169,
          "sha256": "c510ee81f5d50f83099e4cd50febecfcabbfbf05182ce85285d87cf6d138affa"
        },
        "full_frame_14s": {
          "file": "review/rally-wan-14s.jpg",
          "bytes": 304799,
          "sha256": "ed9c904adf676fd293ae3fdd9a587fb2f575ed2a213b247b14d885d5ae20ad01"
        }
      },
      "machine_evidence_sha256": {
        "receipt_sha256": "d9e05cb16f2670b5306022239963cd6c262830c6b3c7aa67bffdfc56256cc344",
        "campaign_sha256": "5ca12ef2f1ae95834e15e2f6fa9136cf228bddd16aed06b36625661eeff2ed62",
        "controller_result_sha256": "3be805698ad2241aeedfcae342211b1b3024462243ef28d65a0573904bebb85b",
        "result_sha256": "65d779d81a3631b6e957813fb47871ca171d66cbb10b5a1f2d0b37a9fcd907f8",
        "blind_audio_sha256": "d3c221b9910ab649b8b42027729da6ab1c9ee9de09e7215decc727f3872e7eba",
        "audio_video_sha256": "15e66e59e98a69faaf161d4a3ca8fe422d385bc69cbef70135dac668474ef680"
      },
      "machine_generation_profile": "thinker-concise-prose-v3",
      "machine_report_termination": {
        "blind_audio": {
          "complete": true,
          "ended_with_eos": true,
          "eos_positions_1based": [
            106
          ],
          "eos_token_id": 151645,
          "raw_tokens_preserved": true,
          "stop_reason": "eos",
          "terminal_token_id": 151645
        },
        "audio_video": {
          "complete": true,
          "ended_with_eos": true,
          "eos_positions_1based": [
            85
          ],
          "eos_token_id": 151645,
          "raw_tokens_preserved": true,
          "stop_reason": "eos",
          "terminal_token_id": 151645
        }
      },
      "machine_report_token_limit_reached": {
        "blind_audio": false,
        "audio_video": false
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "turtle-ltx",
      "video_sha256": "b284bf903e77c2e771f7778a62a61528cb7638f4ddc53572d76e37a10b757891",
      "frame_evidence": {
        "sample_seconds": [
          0,
          1,
          2,
          3,
          4,
          5,
          6,
          7,
          8,
          9,
          10,
          11,
          12,
          13,
          14
        ],
        "contact": {
          "file": "review/turtle-ltx-contact.jpg",
          "bytes": 449806,
          "sha256": "6856dd169abc6d310c2edbc40419dce2378f2f3c4dc30c78cf0e4f80a7e38a19"
        },
        "full_frame_14s": {
          "file": "review/turtle-ltx-14s.jpg",
          "bytes": 262706,
          "sha256": "219dc8a6f16e2eef4094ecff4b6666a9a587265e22e39fb96a1ed9073f934ec8"
        }
      },
      "machine_evidence_sha256": {
        "receipt_sha256": "c2955b19a6fbc3eeaebfce960e759cb68eee41b1d27f443309511b57206d0231",
        "campaign_sha256": "c45401a41507afefbc5e1eba3e715d666c49bc2ce80a98499069355ab3067eb8",
        "controller_result_sha256": "d9a2dbdb3bb3b00289d69c78c77102ef4de4a7882630722d62fed0fb0cdc8b02",
        "result_sha256": "a0fb8431e3f0fcd19682642070bd8a3b0994f9c2d4bb4f56bb7149ffc23a7a3d",
        "blind_audio_sha256": "163fcfe8efd5bc5510d3f0b42566c10c26bc9364727d8f5738e513253f70bd85",
        "audio_video_sha256": "612b9895ff962e61efa53b74c70ca716b6aa7c096310abf9cb0958b1066ada35"
      },
      "machine_generation_profile": "thinker-concise-prose-v3",
      "machine_report_termination": {
        "blind_audio": {
          "complete": true,
          "ended_with_eos": true,
          "eos_positions_1based": [
            68
          ],
          "eos_token_id": 151645,
          "raw_tokens_preserved": true,
          "stop_reason": "eos",
          "terminal_token_id": 151645
        },
        "audio_video": {
          "complete": true,
          "ended_with_eos": true,
          "eos_positions_1based": [
            105
          ],
          "eos_token_id": 151645,
          "raw_tokens_preserved": true,
          "stop_reason": "eos",
          "terminal_token_id": 151645
        }
      },
      "machine_report_token_limit_reached": {
        "blind_audio": false,
        "audio_video": false
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "turtle-wan",
      "video_sha256": "3044669955e0fd14c965468501366cea3054935183666fa35d2fe650fddb0d49",
      "frame_evidence": {
        "sample_seconds": [
          0,
          1,
          2,
          3,
          4,
          5,
          6,
          7,
          8,
          9,
          10,
          11,
          12,
          13,
          14
        ],
        "contact": {
          "file": "review/turtle-wan-contact.jpg",
          "bytes": 274899,
          "sha256": "111cfc8937251b86c44b4e4bd3a47b251e5131f8a10dd6d84022877c4fc0304a"
        },
        "full_frame_14s": {
          "file": "review/turtle-wan-14s.jpg",
          "bytes": 264835,
          "sha256": "167fea76f4228b867b2b921ec187fa7f31c7edcadd3adf50d77d3eb39a605f03"
        }
      },
      "machine_evidence_sha256": {
        "receipt_sha256": "72bfcb94b49f51b98eab215f6e2ba27e14b591e4420d48c4961d0b47c4378c87",
        "campaign_sha256": "fd6f8b37dd4113b14c4c4d6e3a71007700cb09deacc9155556046a3ddb55461f",
        "controller_result_sha256": "3152951402a47b207633df8aa0d1665f1adadbc2cc6c1a3bc0fb57a53ecdc8b6",
        "result_sha256": "47696ea617400e0153574d77326ce58b85eacb654d2c2d1c00f2bc47ecfc36b8",
        "blind_audio_sha256": "91f639f6e8b9745b286884991f1d0f9baaf00fb8d94015e669114350a2b24cf4",
        "audio_video_sha256": "64d7e47be12585643a978852123a7395ef2c18e153db0ee7e7c909045b3ac0ef"
      },
      "machine_generation_profile": "thinker-concise-prose-v3",
      "machine_report_termination": {
        "blind_audio": {
          "complete": true,
          "ended_with_eos": true,
          "eos_positions_1based": [
            73
          ],
          "eos_token_id": 151645,
          "raw_tokens_preserved": true,
          "stop_reason": "eos",
          "terminal_token_id": 151645
        },
        "audio_video": {
          "complete": true,
          "ended_with_eos": true,
          "eos_positions_1based": [
            90
          ],
          "eos_token_id": 151645,
          "raw_tokens_preserved": true,
          "stop_reason": "eos",
          "terminal_token_id": 151645
        }
      },
      "machine_report_token_limit_reached": {
        "blind_audio": false,
        "audio_video": false
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "turtle-lightwan",
      "video_sha256": "ada16943682984d9b9a1a900310c6681cd02e53178dbd50f4bd325cda1ee9d1f",
      "frame_evidence": {
        "sample_seconds": [
          0,
          1,
          2,
          3,
          4,
          5,
          6,
          7,
          8,
          9,
          10,
          11,
          12,
          13,
          14
        ],
        "contact": {
          "file": "review/turtle-lightwan-contact.jpg",
          "bytes": 457818,
          "sha256": "fefc53fdb9c3766c28ed4ac8d8e95c9fafc26b7d64ef690af46b00bd284f7525"
        },
        "full_frame_14s": {
          "file": "review/turtle-lightwan-14s.jpg",
          "bytes": 324375,
          "sha256": "7c1bb9248e97e0eb9cff6699a6ea6725f938e01e6d798e246e1e7f4e08747165"
        }
      },
      "machine_evidence_sha256": {
        "receipt_sha256": "0154f3f9d84c4b672dcbc3c5f68c4e59b4fb6b62ac548b4fc8a0f1343f0b97d1",
        "campaign_sha256": "d814231b17ca6df8160605abcf92bd0d27db1c3d6e2da7b5f5838ad898f11f79",
        "controller_result_sha256": "46935781441114ab8d0b9c55613465eb090a9df2d59c9b3d96a7ef44d589fd08",
        "result_sha256": "91351064cc5e6caa9db5aa8e791135c71c9b06c41865065851df58d94eaff214",
        "blind_audio_sha256": "b15d60c4820af80a86440b901c53251256750140af6d94f3d982072fb9644ae0",
        "audio_video_sha256": "f03cf5e4dd374702783045776771a0cb5d44b9659799c859834ce91417ef200b"
      },
      "machine_generation_profile": "thinker-concise-prose-v3",
      "machine_report_termination": {
        "blind_audio": {
          "complete": true,
          "ended_with_eos": true,
          "eos_positions_1based": [
            107
          ],
          "eos_token_id": 151645,
          "raw_tokens_preserved": true,
          "stop_reason": "eos",
          "terminal_token_id": 151645
        },
        "audio_video": {
          "complete": true,
          "ended_with_eos": true,
          "eos_positions_1based": [
            94
          ],
          "eos_token_id": 151645,
          "raw_tokens_preserved": true,
          "stop_reason": "eos",
          "terminal_token_id": 151645
        }
      },
      "machine_report_token_limit_reached": {
        "blind_audio": false,
        "audio_video": false
      }
    }
  ]
}